
Blog by Hoogbruin & Company, a Vancouver litigation firm since 1987 · 1166 Alberni Street, Vancouver, BC · Last updated November, 2026.
When a landlord refuses to renew a commercial lease in BC and the tenant holds a valid renewal option or relied on a clear promise of renewal, the tenant may have rights that can be enforced. Even where the tenancy does end, the tenant’s deposit, improvements and final costs still require protection.
Before responding to a notice of non-renewal, a tenant should confirm four points:
- Renewal option: whether the lease contains an option to renew and what conditions attach to it.
- Notice deadline: whether the window to exercise that option is still open, and how notice must be delivered.
- Written assurances: whether any emails, letters or messages record a promise of renewal.
- Exit terms: what the lease says about the security deposit, leasehold improvements and restoration.
This blog post explains how commercial lease renewal works in BC, what tenants are entitled to, and the situations in which a non-renewal becomes a legal dispute. Hoogbruin & Company, a Vancouver litigation firm since 1987, advises and represents business tenants such as restaurants, retail stores, clinics and light industrial operators across Vancouver, Burnaby and Richmond when a renewal disagreement can no longer be resolved through negotiation. For background on the most frequent disagreements, see our overview of commercial lease renewal disputes.
Does a Landlord Have to Renew a Commercial Lease in BC?
As a general rule, a landlord does not have to renew. Commercial leases in BC are governed primarily by the terms of the lease itself rather than by the protective rules that apply to residential tenancies. There is no automatic right to renew a commercial lease.
Where a lease expires without a renewal option or another enforceable right, the landlord may decline to renew and is not obliged to provide a reason. The qualification is important, however, because many tenants do hold such rights without recognizing their significance.
When Does a Renewal Option Prevent a Landlord From Refusing to Renew a Commercial Lease?
A properly worded option to renew is a contractual right that the landlord cannot disregard. It entitles the tenant to extend the lease on the terms set out in the clause, provided the option is exercised correctly and within the required time.
Precision is essential. Most renewal options require written notice within a defined window, commonly 90 to 180 days before the lease expires. A tenant who misses that window may lose the right entirely. A tenant who exercises the option properly is entitled to the renewal.
Renewal options frequently raise further questions, such as how “market rent” is to be determined for the new term, or whether a minor default under the existing lease affects the tenant’s right to renew. These questions are often the starting point of a dispute, as discussed below.
What If Landlord Refuses to Renew the Commercial Lease but Never Put It in Writing?
This situation arises more often than it should be. A landlord may indicate, in conversation or by email, that the lease will be renewed. Relying on that assurance, the tenant invests in improvements, hires staff, enters supplier contracts or declines alternative premises, and the renewal is never granted.
In certain circumstances, the law may prevent a party from going back on a promise where the other party reasonably relied on it and would suffer harm as a result. This is not a straightforward remedy, and the outcome depends heavily on the facts. Tenants should therefore preserve every email, text message, and document that records what was said and when.
Where the landlord is ending the tenancy to renovate or redevelop the property, different considerations may apply. Our article on commercial tenants’ rights during landlord renovations and redevelopments explains these in more detail.
What Should a Tenant Protect After a Commercial Lease Non-Renewal?
Even when a commercial lease non-renewal cannot be prevented, the end of the tenancy involves significant financial interests. Business owners often concentrate on securing new premises and overlook amounts they are owed or may be asked to pay.
The security deposit is the first consideration. The lease sets out when it must be returned and on what conditions, and any deductions should be supported by a clear accounting.
Leasehold improvements are the second. The lease determines who owns renovations, fixtures and fits out at the end of the term, and whether the tenant must restore the premises. For restaurants and clinics with significant buildouts, restoration can be costly, so tenants should understand their actual obligations before returning to possession.
Finally, year-end items such as operating cost reconciliations and property tax adjustments should be reviewed carefully, as they may result in amounts owing in either direction.
When Does a Landlord’s Refusal to Renew a Commercial Lease Become a Dispute?
Many non-renewals conclude without conflict. A refusal to renew becomes a legal dispute when the parties disagree about the tenant’s rights and cannot resolve that disagreement between themselves. Common examples include the following:
- The tenant exercised a renewal option, but the landlord refuses to honour it or claims the notice was late or improperly delivered.
- The landlord asserts that a minor default under the current lease cancels the tenant’s right to renew.
- The parties cannot agree on the renewal rent, and the lease’s “market rent” or arbitration provisions are in question.
- The tenant relied on a promise of renewal and has incurred losses as a result of the landlord withdrawing it.
- The landlord withholds the security deposit or makes deductions the tenant considers unjustified.
- The landlord demands restoration work or payments that go beyond what the lease requires.
In each of these situations, timing affects the tenant’s position. Once a renewal window has passed, a surrender agreement has been signed or the premises have been vacated; the available options narrow considerably.
How Can Hoogbruin & Company Help Protect Commercial Tenant Rights in BC When a Dispute Arises?
When a dispute arises, Hoogbruin & Company can help tenants understand their commercial tenant rights in BC and, if required, represent their case in court. Our lawyers review the lease to confirm whether a valid renewal option or other enforceable right exists, assess whether a landlord’s assurances may be actionable, and pursue the return of deposits and fair treatment of improvements and final adjustments.
Tenants who have received notice of non-renewal, or who have been offered renewal only on terms they consider unreasonable, benefit from obtaining advice before taking any irreversible step. Our commercial litigation lawyers in Vancouver act for businesses in Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond and across Metro Vancouver in lease disputes, from early negotiation through to litigation.
What Do BC Commercial Tenants Commonly Ask About Lease Non-Renewal?
Can a commercial landlord in BC refuse renewal without explanation?
Unless the tenant holds a renewal option or another enforceable right, the landlord generally has no legal obligation to renew or to provide a reason.
What happens if a tenant misses the deadline to exercise a renewal option?
The tenant may lose the right to renew. Courts may grant relief in exceptional circumstances, but this is not guaranteed, so tenants should act promptly.
Is the landlord required to return the security deposit?
The lease sets out the terms. Tenants should review the deposit clause carefully and document the condition of the premises before vacating.
Can a tenant remain in the premises after the commercial lease expires?
A tenant who stays on after expiry without a renewal usually becomes a month-to-month tenant under the lease’s overholding clause, often at a higher rent. The landlord can generally end that arrangement on short notice, so remaining in place does not preserve the tenant’s negotiating position.
Should a tenant sign a surrender or move-out agreement offered by the landlord?
A tenant should have any surrender or move-out agreement reviewed before signing. These agreements often settle the deposit, restoration and final adjustments, and they may release claims the tenant would otherwise be entitled to pursue.
If your landlord has refused to renew your commercial lease and a dispute has arisen, contact Hoogbruin & Company or call 604-609-3783 to arrange a lease review with a BC commercial lease lawyer.
This post provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice on your commercial dispute circumstances, request a case evaluation with our commercial litigation lawyer.

